- Joined
- Sep 19, 2018
- Messages
- 6,070
- SL Rez
- 2002
- Joined SLU
- Nov 2003
- SLU Posts
- 35836
This is an important Tweet thread:
I'm pretty sure I recall reading somewhere that when they came to choose a design for the new Palace of Westminster after the old one was destroyed by a fire in 1834, during a period of considerable economic and political upheaval and the Chartist Movement agitating for a broadened suffrage, making the new buildings readily defensible against mobs and demonstrators was an important consideration (it's said to be why one wall is over the river, so it can't be surrounded and so, in an emergency, members can be evacuated by water).I’ve been saying the same since it started. The last attack on Canadian parliament resulted in the assailant shot 31 times, including by the Sargent at Arms in full ceremonial robes. Some say it’s different when it’s a mob, and maybe so, but I feel like it indicates something else that’s fundamentally different about Americans and their relationship with their government than exists in other countries? I’m just not sure what.
Edit to add, I’ve had to visit the provincial Legislature several times for work, and couldn’t imagine a mob getting through security even when the premier isn’t in the building, let alone the extra security when they are in session.
I would not be surprised if there were Canadians there. Several pro Trump rallies protesting certifying the US election were held across Canada AT THE SAME TIME as the insurrection at the Capitol. One just two hours away from me. Ironically they were broken up and charged with violating public health orders on social gatherings during a pandemic.Another video of the violence... one thing I find interesting is the flags they are waiving in this video. It's not just American and Trump and confederate flags. They have Canadian, French, Korean, and even Scottish flags. Like, WTF? I mean, I always thought they liked the American flag and standing for it at sports ball games because of the patriotism they feel for America, but no... it's not about the American flag, specifically. They just categorically like all flags. ALL FLAGS MATTER! LOL
That's so weird. I don't understand Trump's appeal in other countries. I hear he has a big following in Poland. Do foreigners not understand what, "America first!" means? I guess nationalism to a specific country is kind of a fluid thing to people of a certain ideological bent. I mean, we have American nazis, even though nazis were German nationalists, so I guess I shouldn't be surprised. It just makes me scratch my head.I would not be surprised if there were Canadians there. Several pro Trump rallies protesting certifying the US election were held across Canada AT THE SAME TIME as the insurrection at the Capitol. One just two hours away from me. Ironically they were broken up and charged with violating public health orders on social gatherings during a pandemic.
My cousin is frothing on Facebook about how we’ve all been duped and Antifa plotted the whole thing.
Whatever this sickness is, it’s definitely not an American thing. We are usually a year or two behind you so many Canadians are watching closely and thinking maybe dismissing or ignoring the fringe isn’t the best solution after all.

I don't think it's American nationalism that has struck a chord with other people around the world, particularly in Europe. Trump may have used the words "America First", but in actuality, that was a dogwhistle for white supremacy - for it's not ALL of America that comes first for him and his ilk, but WHITE America. And that resonates with other white supremacists around the world.That's so weird. I don't understand Trump's appeal in other countries. I hear he has a big following in Poland. Do foreigners not understand what, "America first!" means? I guess nationalism to a specific country is kind of a fluid thing to people of a certain ideological bent. I mean, we have American nazis, even though nazis were German nationalists, so I guess I shouldn't be surprised. It just makes me scratch my head.
I don't think it's American nationalism that has struck a chord with other people around the world, particularly in Europe. Trump may have used the words "America First", but in actuality, that was a dogwhistle for white supremacy - for it's not ALL of America that comes first for him and his ilk, but WHITE America. And that resonates with other white supremacists around the world.
Alberta has a reputation.As for Canada, there have always been a subset here who envy US might - who prefer to identify with the brute than with weak pinko “sorry, eh?” effeminate Canada.
It's been a puzzler here in my state for decades. There's even a book about it, "What's the Matter with Kansas". My state is among the poorest in the country, being mostly rural and sparsely populated. But the backlash to the post-war Communist threat has completely immersed our brains in this weird fantasy that we're the ones who are right, we all have the chance to be fabulously rich, and those other guys worship Satan and eat babies.That's the bit I don't get -- why are people in the American midwest, for example, so scared of socialists when they've probably never met one in their lives, and they tend to agree with socialist policies anyway, if they hear the policy described without being told whose it is?
I know we dump on Alberta a lot because of their more conservative politics but to be fair, you will find the same sorts all across Canada. Just more divided and less concentrated, with less (past) oil/US money pumping them up. Thank heavens for all the Pancake, read sane, people who still live there.Alberta has a reputation.
Imagine if instead of using Socialism at every turn during and after the war, they would have used the words fascism and dictatorship more. I wonder if that would have made a difference.It's been a puzzler here in my state for decades. There's even a book about it, "What's the Matter with Kansas". My state is among the poorest in the country, being mostly rural and sparsely populated. But the backlash to the post-war Communist threat has completely immersed our brains in this weird fantasy that we're the ones who are right, we all have the chance to be fabulously rich, and those other guys worship Satan and eat babies.
Most of my discussions with people on the topic involve pointless "whataboutism" involving Stalin's purges and Mao's agrarian reforms. Because, as we're all so painfully aware, those are absolutely the only examples ofsocialist democracycommies in the history of ever.
Isabeau is correct, every province has its own brand of crazy. Alberta is just the most vocal and proud of it, and it’s the most American like and recognizable.I know we dump on Alberta a lot because of their more conservative politics but to be fair, you will find the same sorts all across Canada. Just more divided and less concentrated, with less (past) oil/US money pumping them up. Thank heavens for all the Pancake, read sane, people who still live there.