- Joined
- Sep 20, 2018
- Messages
- 23,836
- SLU Posts
- 18459
Your comment is an excellent example of the antisemite's syllogism, as explained by Howard Jacobson in his book When Will Jews Be Forgiven The Holocaust?Sure, I'll withdrawal my statement and hopefully it will sanitize this genocide within acceptable boundaries. I'm not well-versed in mass murder etiquette.
But does Israel really try to separate church and state? That's news to me.
It has for a long time been argued that pro-Israeli Jews deliberately conflate all criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism in order to silence their opponents. If there were Jews who deliberately did such a thing, or still do so in their hearts, there will be very few impolitic enough to do it openly any longer. The point has been well taken: yes, you can be a critic of the settlements, the occupation, Gaza . . . not sure about the country’s right to exist, but OK, you can be a critic of that as well . . . and not be an anti-Semite. What decidedly doesn’t follow from that, however, is that so long as you are a critic of Israel you cannot be an anti-Semite. Yet that, by false syllogism, is the point at which we have arrived.
The syllogism goes like this:
Not all critics of Israel are anti-Semites.
I am a critic of Israel.
Therefore I am not an anti-Semite.
In this way has anti-Zionism become an inviolable space.














