bubblesort
Well-known member
- Joined
- Nov 16, 2018
- Messages
- 1,990
I think you're just doing everything you can do ignore that Gamestop is a solvent company, with a solid business model. Objectively speaking, they're still around, still doing business, regardless of what Melvin and their buddies said, and regardless of the hedge fund industry's sleazy machinations. You can play with the analysis of what happened with their stock and reddit and this character or that character all day long, but at the end of the day... the people who believed that gamestop is not going bankrupt were objectively correct, and the people thinking they were going under were objectively wrong, and that's why Melvin Capital is bankrupt right now, and I can still go to Gamestop to buy pokemon plushies any time I want.I don't think that theory works because again, Gill bought his Gamestop stock and was already at least trying to hype it on his YouTube channel before he got fired; in fact I think I read that he first bought the stock back in 2019. I do believe that he dramatically ramped up his efforts after he got fired because you're right, what he did basically meant that he would have a very hard time finding another actual job in the industry. Gill's manipulations basically created his own golden parachute.
The narrative that what people did was "sticking it to Wall Street" only works if Melvin Capital was doing something immoral or unethical. But that in turn would only be true of Melvin was literally engaging in some kind of market manipulation to MAKE Gamestop's stock fall - and there's legitimately no evidence of that. Gamestop's stock had been falling very steadily for several years - in fact it's been steadily falling ever since a short-lived high in 2013. You could slice cheese with that line it's so straight. That's the whole reason the stock was being shorted so heavily - the stock was reliably losing value, there was no need for Melvin Capital or anyone else to have to manipulate a drop. There's no sudden dips or anything in the line that hints at any funny business going on.
I think Gill and his cohorts knew that much, and that's why they did their best to try to portray short selling, as in, the concept all by itself, as inherently unethical - like Melvin Capital short-selling Gamestop stock was the thing that was killing the company. But it's not. Short-selling is just a bet, and the only thing that's at stake is the bettor's own money. Gamestop was losing value for like some extremely logical social, tech, and market reasons - the same basic kinds of reasons that Radio Shack and Sam Goody aren't around anymore.
There's an anti-capitalist argument that Wall Street as a group - as in, all of the actors - are bad because capitalism is bad; but that argument doesn't exempt individual traders; capitalists preying on other capitalists is just another road on the same social inequality map.
Last edited:













