The Telegraph, whose nickname is the Torygraph, published an internal BBC memo today.
The 19 page long internal memo was created by Michael Prescott, a former advisor to the BBC's Editorial Guidelines and Standards Committee until June 2025. So his memo is about how BBC abides to editorial standards or not. The memo was shared with the BBC board and Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS). Prescott is accusing the BBC of multiple, serious breaches of impartiality and editorial standards.
1. Editing of Trump's January 6, 2021 speech: A Panorama episode ("Trump: A Second Chance?") aired shortly before the 2024 US election allegedly "doctored" and spliced clips from different parts of the speech (nearly an hour apart), making it appear Trump explicitly encouraged the Capitol riot by combining phrases like "peacefully and patriotically make your voices heard" with "fight like hell." Footage of marchers was also used out of sequence to imply they responded directly to his words. Prescott called this "completely misleading," and executives reportedly refused to acknowledge a breach despite internal reviews.
2. Pro-Hamas Bias in Gaza/Israel coverage, especially within BBC Arabic: The service allegedly minimized Israeli suffering (e.g., ignoring child deaths in attacks, portraying terror incidents as "military operations"), amplified Hamas-provided casualty figures without scrutiny, platformed pro-Hamas or antisemitic commentators hundreds of times, and "raced" anti-Israel claims to air without checks—suggesting "carelessness or a desire always to believe the worst about Israel." Stark differences existed between BBC Arabic and English coverage, painting Israel as the aggressor and spreading Hamas propaganda.
3. One-sided trans/gender coverage: Prescott is criticising, that the internal LGBTQ+ desk within BBC has been constantly delivering one-sided pro trans/gender coverage only, while letting critic towards it fall between the cracks willingly.
The BBC so far says it takes feedback seriously, but declined to comment on the document specifically.
This article shows the BBC edit of Trump's speech vs. the original clip.
Access Restricted
Here is the full internal memo:
Access Restricted
In short the Tories and UKIP are fuming united, saying "Told you so" and demanding consequences.
A cross-party group of MPs in the HoC has commented it with the BBC has "serious questions to answer."
An episode of Panorama is accused of misleading viewers with its editing of a speech by Donald Trump.
www.bbc.com