The term "defund the police" or what was also heard at the time "abolish the police" got my hair sticking up on its head. The reason for that was that I live in a high-crime neighborhood. We were already being under-served in a severe manner. We either get no police response at all or we get crazy trigger-happy cops; very little in-between.
I'm not alone. Nekima Levy Armstrong, our previous NAACP president didn't like it either. She conducted peaceful protests at my own 4th precinct when they murdered Jamar Clark. I attended those. She felt, as I do, that some people who were justifiably outraged following the murder of George Floyd were not thinking their plan through, exactly. The people it would hurt would be those most vulnerable to either the criminals or the cops. She also wasn't happy that black voices were NOT being listened to, in particular our police chief Arrondondo.
While the movement to defund the police has been driven by Black activists, others say that city politicians rushed the process and failed to include a police chief who has the backing of many Black residents.
www.startribune.com
I agree that "demilitarize the pollce" or even something like "stop murdering us" would have been more helpful. Our City Council was very knee-jerk in their responses. Lisa Bender, the white leader of the council, was the most vocal and strident voice of abolishing the police. I don't have much respect for her, as you can guess. She lived in the Lowry Hill neighborhood, a white and wealthy enclave. When she faced backlash, she had round-the-clock security, on our dime. Not a single person who lives in dangerous areas got such a thing, as crime here exploded. I see her as a do-gooder who has all these ideas that she doesn't have to live with; no understanding of the entirety of the issues.
I DO understand the impulse. Burn it all down and create something better. I just question the impulsiveness of not having something planned, BEFORE making such calls. Social workers going out to domestic violence calls? No. They will be dead social workers as that is one of the most volatile situations. Don't forget that a pretty high majority of mass murderers have a domestic violence history. A lot of the people these social workers will be asked to contend with are armed and VERY angry at the time of contact.
Anyhow, just my thoughts on it.