Letters from Mexico

Beebo Brink

Climate Apocalypse Alarmist
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
6,371
SL Rez
2006
I had a startling moment of clarity this week as I realized that I know nothing about politics in Mexico, despite the country being right on our border, and despite the fact that I am half-Mexican. There are no voices on the forum from Mexico to provide the sort of insights that I get daily from Canadian, British and European forum members.

This epiphany was triggered by a letter from a Mexican cousin of mine who has recently moved to Spain. Here are some excerpts from her reply to my latest personal expression of dismay at what is happening under the Trump Administration:

Reading your email has been quite an experience. It feels like you’re describing what we’ve been living in Mexico over the past few years with an authoritarian government that hides behind “the people” who elected them. We have been watching the destruction of all institutions of transparency, science, education, and cooperation; the destruction of the Justice System by passing laws that only benefit the group in power; and above all, the terrible polarization that cuts across social classes and ideologies — it has all been heartbreaking.

Every morning, since 2018, the President — the “Mexican Messiah” and now the President Claudia Sheinbaum— sets the media and public discourse agenda from her pulpit (a three-hour-long program we call “las mañaneras”). There, it is dictated whom to follow, whom to accuse, and whom to denigrate, all in the name of the Mexican poor people who often understand very little of politics and simply thank them for the few coins handed out in exchange for their votes.

We had hoped the country would change with a leftist option. The problem is, it wasn’t truly leftist. Instead, we’ve ended up with an authoritarian populism with power concentrated in one man: Andrés Manuel López Obrador — the man behind the new President — and soon to be inherited by his biological sons, who are already involved in politics.

The problem is, we’re paralyzed. No one says anything. No one does anything. When I see the protests in Barcelona for any issue — lack of housing for the youth, electricity prices, the war in Ukraine — at least thousands take to the streets, or hundreds of thousands when it’s about feminism or public policies. We feel citizenship here, and that feeling is incredibly empowering. It’s very sad to see that in our country people don’t take the streets, whether out of indifference, fear, or complacency. I think we’re already a lost cause.

In the end, we burned our ships and returned to Barcelona. We’ll apply for citizenship to avoid all the migration paperwork, but we’re already beneficiaries of the public health system, which is a luxury. I just had surgery on an eye I could barely see with — and I didn’t pay a cent.

As the years go by and health deteriorates, it’s very reassuring to live in a country that guarantees a good level of free, high-quality healthcare. Plus, Barcelona is a beautiful, multicultural city with great food, walkability, a manageable size, and a fairly mild climate… Above all, we live without fear — and that’s priceless, something you can no longer say in Mexico.

Trump — what can I say to you about Trump? Just that things will go very badly for Mexico, worse than for other countries, and that will spark more violence and greater recruitment of youth into drug trafficking as thousands of jobs disappear due to U.S. pressure to companies to leave the country. We bet everything on the trade agreement with the U.S. and Canada, which makes up over 90% of our exports. It’s predicted that our GDP could fall by up to 7%. A national disaster.

Anyway, dear cousin , we can only wish that you take the best from life and leave behind the worst. Dogs, cats, and love is the prescription for these days. We send you our love and we’ll stay in touch.
.
 

Kamilah Hauptmann

Shitpost Sommelier
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
14,281
Location
Cat Country (Can't Stop Here)
SL Rez
2005
Joined SLU
Reluctantly
Every morning, since 2018, the President — the “Mexican Messiah” and now the President Claudia Sheinbaum— sets the media and public discourse agenda from her pulpit (a three-hour-long program we call “las mañaneras”). There, it is dictated whom to follow, whom to accuse, and whom to denigrate, all in the name of the Mexican poor people who often understand very little of politics and simply thank them for the few coins handed out in exchange for their votes.
This is almost precisely what happened in Venezuela under Chavismo.
 

GoblinCampFollower

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
4,064
SL Rez
2007
I also admit to knowing very little about Mexican politics. This letter was very interesting and I'm sure there was some truth to it. ....but I really want to caution against putting too much trust in any ONE source, including family members. I have a number of relatives who I'd not trust to teach a foreigner anything about US politics for example.

Every morning, since 2018, the President — the “Mexican Messiah” and now the President Claudia Sheinbaum— sets the media and public discourse agenda from her pulpit (a three-hour-long program we call “las mañaneras”). There, it is dictated whom to follow, whom to accuse, and whom to denigrate, all in the name of the Mexican poor people who often understand very little of politics and simply thank them for the few coins handed out in exchange for their votes.

We had hoped the country would change with a leftist option. The problem is, it wasn’t truly leftist. Instead, we’ve ended up with an authoritarian populism with power concentrated in one man: Andrés Manuel López Obrador — the man behind the new President — and soon to be inherited by his biological sons, who are already involved in politics.
I admit English language sources of Mexican politics are probably dubious and mostly non existent; but in particular, I couldn't find anything to confirm that Andrés Manuel López Obrador is at all still in power. This doesn't prove your cousin is wrong, but I can't help but think this comes off as a bit like conspiracy theorist thinking.

I also admit it is possible the cousin is completely right and English Language sources are just completely dropping the ball here.
 

Isabeau

Merdeuse
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
8,173
Location
Montréal
SL Rez
2007
Her cousin doesn’t say that he is still in power (she mentions Sheinbaum earlier in the post) she was talking about him and what he did while being the previous president before her.

I’m pretty sure Beebo is capable of looking on line for more info and not wholly depending on one source.
 
  • 1Thanks
  • 1Agree
Reactions: Ellie and Govi

Beebo Brink

Climate Apocalypse Alarmist
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
6,371
SL Rez
2006
This letter was very interesting and I'm sure there was some truth to it. ....but I really want to caution against putting too much trust in any ONE source, including family members. I have a number of relatives who I'd not trust to teach a foreigner anything about US politics for example.
I offered this take on Mexican politics for what it is: one person's perspective.

For what it's worth, however, I'd put my cousin on par with the most knowledgeable political voices on this forum. Before retiring, she was an upper-level manager in industry, and she and her brothers all grew up in a very political household. My uncle, their father, held a substantial position in Mexico City government back in the day. So she's basically a Mexican version of bronxelf or Innula in her ability to offer insights into the current political landscape of her country.
 

GoblinCampFollower

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
4,064
SL Rez
2007
Her cousin doesn’t say that he is still in power (she mentions Sheinbaum earlier in the post) she was talking about him and what he did while being the previous president before her.
The letter refers to him as "the man behind the new President" which seems like a strong statement to me... Though maybe she just meant that he setup the new President or something like that.

I’m pretty sure Beebo is capable of looking on line for more info and not wholly depending on one source.
Never meant to say she wasn't... but we all have biases around family members. I know I've been guilty of placing too much trust in people I knew and loved before. My doubt is less about doubting Beebo and more just how I'd react to any such new piece of information that I couldn't find corresponding sources for.

I offered this take on Mexican politics for what it is: one person's perspective.

For what it's worth, however, I'd put my cousin on par with the most knowledgeable political voices on this forum. Before retiring, she was an upper-level manager in industry, and she and her brothers all grew up in a very political household. My uncle, their father, held a substantial position in Mexico City government back in the day. So she's basically a Mexican version of bronxelf or Innula in her ability to offer insights into the current political landscape of her country.
Thanks. I don't mean any disrespect. Just that their words are a bit shocking. If you have good reason to trust their credibility then this is disturbing for sure.
 
Last edited:

detrius

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
1,998
Location
Land of bread, beer and BMW.
Joined SLU
09-30-2007
SLU Posts
10065
I had a startling moment of clarity this week as I realized that I know nothing about politics in Mexico, despite the country being right on our border[...]
I'm always so proud for remembering Liechtenstein that I forget it's actually not a neighbouring country. (It's nestled between Austria and Switzerland, 24 km south of Lake Constance.)
 

Soen Eber

Vatican mole
VVO Supporter 🍦🎈👾❤
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
3,611
I'm ashamed to say I may know more about some European countries than I do about the minority populations in my own city. I've tried to make amends in that knowledge gap, but I've been inconsistent and sporadic.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: Ellie

GoblinCampFollower

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
4,064
SL Rez
2007
I'm always so proud for remembering Liechtenstein that I forget it's actually not a neighbouring country. (It's nestled between Austria and Switzerland, 24 km south of Lake Constance.)
LMAO... something kind of related that I've thought about is how often we hear about a country relative to how many people they got. Bangladesh, Nigeria and Indonesia for example all have well over 100M people but I never hear about them in our media. Most media outlets care more about news in countries that are white and/or rich.
 

Beebo Brink

Climate Apocalypse Alarmist
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
6,371
SL Rez
2006
I don't mean any disrespect. Just that their words are a bit shocking. If you have good reason to trust their credibility then this is disturbing for sure.
Consider, for a moment, that all of us hanging out in the PRS forum are political animals, who are well informed about the general political landscape of the U.S., Canada, Britain and Europe, even China. And so far, NO ONE on VVO has any idea whether the statements from my cousin are a reasonable description of what is happening in Mexico.

Your reaction is merely a confirmation of my opening:
I had a startling moment of clarity this week as I realized that I know nothing about politics in Mexico, despite the country being right on our border, and despite the fact that I am half-Mexican. There are no voices on the forum from Mexico to provide the sort of insights that I get daily from Canadian, British and European forum members.
I can't remember a single article about Mexican politics appearing in any of the news sources that I usually read. So now I'm going to dig deeper to see what I've been missing.
 
Last edited:

Beebo Brink

Climate Apocalypse Alarmist
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
6,371
SL Rez
2006
Mexico elects Claudia Sheinbaum as its first female president in landslide victory | Mexico | The Guardian

As it relates to the letter that started this thread, I noticed these sections (bolded emphasis is mine), which confirm the close association of Obrador and Sheinbaum. To what extent he directly influences her actions is open to the same speculation we engage in over how much influence Musk or Voight have over Trump.

Claudia Sheinbaum has won a landslide victory to become Mexico’s first female president, inheriting the project of her mentor and outgoing leader, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, whose popularity among the poor helped drive her triumph.

Sheinbaum, a leftwing climate scientist and former mayor of Mexico City, won the presidency with between 58.3% and 60.7% of the vote, according to a rapid sample count by Mexico’s electoral authority.
Sheinbaum is also the first woman to win a general election in the US, Mexico or Canada.

Her victory exceeds the 54.71% achieved by her populist mentor López Obrador in 2018. He wrote on X: “I congratulate Claudia Sheinbaum, who triumphed by a wide margin. She’ll be the first female president of Mexico in 200 years … And she may also be the president with most votes in all the history of our country.”

Then there was this, which doesn't sound good for the stability of the country:
Aside from the presidency, more than 20,000 posts were up for grabs in Mexico’s biggest election. The poll has also been the most violent in modern history, with more than 30 candidates killed and hundreds more dropping out as criminal groups vied to install friendly leaders.

This next observation tracks with my cousin's skepticism over leftist populism covering for authoritarianism:
[Sheinbaum] vowed to continue [Obrador's] policies, including cash transfers to elderly people and single mothers, and flagship infrastructure projects in historically poor regions, but also a massively expanded role for the military in areas typically reserved for civil society, such as domestic security.

And finally, there's this jewel:
López Obrador's mañaneras in Mexico a unique form of communication marked by attacks on the press - LatAm Journalism Review by the Knight Center
On Dec. 3, 2018, the newly inaugurated president of Mexico, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, announced that starting at 6 a.m. every day – from Monday to Friday – he would hold a press conference to discuss the most important issues in the country.

From that moment on, the president, usually in the company of ministers or other officials, holds a press conference that can last up to three hours. This way of communication started to be popularized under the name “mañanera.”...Indeed, las mañaneras have become the main way that López Obrador communicates with his followers, and have been recognized as a change from previous presidents when giving public statements.

However, some say they have also been identified as favorable spaces for attacking media and journalists, and even for the spread of disinformation.
Overall, I'd say that I'm inclined to trust my cousin's perspective on current events in Mexico.
 

Bartholomew Gallacher

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 26, 2018
Messages
6,101
SL Rez
2002
Well Sheinbaum has the balls to fight back against Trump as a woman. She rejected the offer of American occupation helper troops at the border, which enraged Trump.


Also contrary to Trump her approval rates in Mexico are sky high. It was at 85% after being 6 months in the office.

 

GoblinCampFollower

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
4,064
SL Rez
2007
Yes, I get that he endorsed her. I just felt that the words in the letter made it sound like she was just a puppet... but maybe she is? I agree I'm feeling more inclined to trust your cousin now.

And finally, there's this jewel:
López Obrador's mañaneras in Mexico a unique form of communication marked by attacks on the press - LatAm Journalism Review by the Knight Center
Overall, I'd say that I'm inclined to trust my cousin's perspective on current events in Mexico.
Thank you. And yes, I think you proved your point. I'm sure you can also understand why I was initially a bit suspicious just because the news was shocking. The very SMALL amount of coverage she's gotten in the USA was very favorable.... so this all came as a bit of a surprise, but I think you proved your point.
 

Beebo Brink

Climate Apocalypse Alarmist
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
6,371
SL Rez
2006
Thank you. And yes, I think you proved your point. I'm sure you can also understand why I was initially a bit suspicious just because the news was shocking.
You persist in interpreting my comments as if I'm personally championing my cousin, as opposed to looking for the same confirmation that you felt was lacking. As I've repeatedly said, I didn't know enough about Mexican politics to do anything more than put forth her view. I was inclined to believe her, because I know her background, but I could not claim any direct knowledge of the situation there. I know a little more today, and yes, it does seem to confirm what she said.

Yes, your reservations were understandable, but you didn't seem to be interested in doing the research yourself after voicing your skepticism. Which was also my larger point, that Mexico and its politics simply don't merit much forum scrutiny. We don't really care what happens south of the American border as compared to our concern for Canadians. I'm as guilty of that as anyone.
 

GoblinCampFollower

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
4,064
SL Rez
2007
You persist in interpreting my comments as if I'm personally championing my cousin, as opposed to looking for the same confirmation that you felt was lacking.
You're taking a hostile interpretation of my comments. I absolutely did try to find confirmation of a few things I commented on and read a few articles and a few wiki pages. ...I just didn't find anything as direct as what you posted. I will admit I of course could have tried harder. ...which is always true. It's not that I didn't try, it's that I failed.

My last comment was just trying to agree with you.
 
  • 1Thanks
Reactions: Beebo Brink

Lexxi

meow
Joined
Sep 26, 2018
Messages
1,218
SL Rez
2007
Joined SLU
12-14-2007
SLU Posts
6381
Consider, for a moment, that all of us hanging out in the PRS forum are political animals, who are well informed about the general political landscape of the U.S., Canada, Britain and Europe, even China. And so far, NO ONE on VVO has any idea whether the statements from my cousin are a reasonable description of what is happening in Mexico.

Your reaction is merely a confirmation of my opening:


I can't remember a single article about Mexican politics appearing in any of the news sources that I usually read. So now I'm going to dig deeper to see what I've been missing.
I used to pay attention to the politics in Mexico. I think that was in the 1990s or 2000s. But after yet another "this person looks super smart, bet they'll do great things" *watches as things get worse, or at least appear that way* I stopped being able to take the punishment of paying attention.

I think the last time I paid close-ish attention to Canada's politics was when Rob Ford was bouncing around. Then died. I still keep mild attention there, so I 'know' things like how the Conservatives were expected to win with a 25 point lead until their candidate lost to the Liberals because of Trump.

Briefly paid attention to New Zealand politics when Jacinda Ardern was PM. Then realized it was just too far away to keep up with.

I've no point, just rambling.
 
  • 1Like
  • 1Hug
Reactions: Ellie and Beebo Brink

GoblinCampFollower

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
4,064
SL Rez
2007
I used to pay attention to the politics in Mexico. I think that was in the 1990s or 2000s. But after yet another "this person looks super smart, bet they'll do great things" *watches as things get worse, or at least appear that way* I stopped being able to take the punishment of paying attention.
One thing I know about Mexican politics is they they've long struggled dearly to deal with the drug trade that is funded mostly with American money. I'm not so sure I want to see all drugs become legal anymore; but the strongest argument to completely end drug prohibition of any kind is to take the wind out of the cartels and gangs who supply them in the black market.

I have also seen many examples of officials in small and/or poor countries take a beating for big global events they have essentially no sway in. I think a lot of brilliant politicians are seen as failures because of events that really were totally out of their control.

I admit to not knowing a lot of detail about Mexican or south American politics, but what I has read has often made a lot of good points about how we've often screwed them over in various ways.